Your Employee Wants to Move to France: What a US Employer Owes

Aurelio Maurici

By Aurelio Maurici Co-Founder, Master of Business Law, Aix-Marseille Université III

Published

This post contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

The Saint-Georges church and the red footbridge over the Saône in Lyon

Picture a call many US founders now get, told here as a hypothetical: a senior engineer on your US payroll says she is moving to Lyon next month, wants to keep her job, and asks whether anything needs to change. Almost everything does. This guide is for founders, HR and finance leads at US companies who face that request. If you are the employee, it is not written for you: read whether remote work for a US company is legal on a visitor visa instead. It covers the rules that change the day she starts working from France, her right to work there, your four options with what each leaves exposed, and a checklist. This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Rules change, and your situation may differ: always verify current requirements with the relevant French authorities or a licensed professional.

What Changes the Day She Starts Working From France

Four sets of rules attach to the place where the work is done, not to where your company is incorporated or where payroll runs:

  • Social security: French contributions are due on her pay, unless a US certificate of coverage applies.
  • Income tax: she becomes a French tax resident, and you withhold French income tax from her salary.
  • Labor law: the protective rules of French employment law apply to her contract, whatever law it names.
  • Corporate tax: depending on what she does, her presence can give your company a taxable presence in France.

A fifth question sits upstream: whether she holds a status that lets her work in France at all.

Social Security: French Contributions Unless a Certificate Applies

The United States and France have had a totalization agreement since July 1, 1988. Under its territoriality rule, as the Social Security Administration explains, an employee who would otherwise be covered by both systems is covered only by the system of the country where she works. CLEISS, the French public body for international social security, applies this to employers based abroad: an employee working in France is compulsorily covered by the French system, from sickness and old age to unemployment, and the foreign employer pays the contributions in France.

A company with no establishment in France goes through one office. The Urssaf service for foreign firms (service Firmes étrangères) covers foreign employers whose employee works permanently in France. The company files a creation declaration on the INPI single window (guichet unique) and a pre-hiring declaration (DPAE), receives a Siret number, then declares and pays contributions monthly, through the payroll filing (DSN) or through the titre firmes étrangères (TFE), a free service that CLEISS describes as optional and open to companies with fewer than 20 employees.

Skipping registration is the expensive path. According to Urssaf’s page on the DPAE, an employer that does not declare a hire faces recovery of the contributions avoided and a penalty of 300 times the hourly minimum guaranteed rate. An intentional failure is concealed employment (travail dissimulé), punished by a fine of up to 225,000 euros for a company.

The Exception: A Temporary Assignment With a Certificate of Coverage

The agreement’s detached-worker rule keeps an employee under US Social Security when her employer sends her abroad for a limited time. SSA describes it as applying to a person temporarily transferred to work for the same employer in another country, generally for assignments expected to last 5 years or less, with contributions paid only to the US program. The SSA and CLEISS pages set the conditions for France:

  • Who asks: the US employer requests the certificate from SSA, online or by mail. The French side calls it form SE 404-02, and since April 1, 2017 it must be available for French inspectors.
  • How long: 5 years at most, and CLEISS’s table shows no extension for the United States. An exceptional derogation can be asked of SSA, with Urssaf’s agreement, when the assignment is planned from the start to last longer.
  • Health insurance: a worker exempted from French contributions cannot receive French health insurance benefits, so SSA’s page on the France agreement requires private health insurance for her and the family living with her before the exemption applies.
  • Dates: the request states the beginning and the end of the assignment.

The rule is written for an assignment the employer decides, with an end date. An employee who relocates for personal reasons with no plan to return does not match that description in our reading of the SSA and CLEISS pages: plan on French coverage, and have the point confirmed before relying on a certificate. The US-France totalization agreement is explained from the employee’s side in a guide of its own.

Your visa decides whether you are allowed to work at all.

What Americans get wrong about moving to France, and the number, form or deadline that fixes it. Straight to your inbox.

One email a week. Real numbers, nothing else.

Income Tax: French Residence and Your Withholding Duty

Under French law, impots.gouv.fr treats a person as tax domiciled in France if any one of three tests is met: the household (foyer) is in France, the person works in France in an activity that is not ancillary, or France is the center of her economic interests. An employee who moves her home to Lyon and works from there meets the first two. If the US also treats her as resident, the tie-breaker of the France-US tax treaty of August 31, 1994 starts with the country where she has a permanent home (article 4), and article 15 lets France tax salaries for work done in France. She keeps filing US returns: US taxes while living in France covers her side, and French tax residency in the year of arrival her first year.

France collects income tax on salaries at source (prélèvement à la source), through the employer. The tax administration’s doctrine states that the employer being established outside France makes in principle no difference, and names employees settled in France who work regularly for a foreign employer with no establishment there (BOFiP, BOI-IR-PAS-10-10-10, § 60). Two consequences follow:

  • A tax representative: an employer not established in France must have a representative established in France, accredited by the tax office for foreign companies (SIEE), who files and pays over the tax withheld. Only employers in the EU or the European Economic Area with assistance agreements are exempt, so a US company is not (BOFiP, BOI-IR-PAS-30-10-10, § 90 and following). The designation comes before the work in France starts.
  • A certificate does not remove it: the same chapter has employers not established in France, whose employee is outside the French general social security system, report the tax on a separate return (PASRAU). Keeping US Social Security does not switch off French withholding.

Labor Law: A US Contract Does Not Shut Out French Rules

Many offer letters choose the law of Delaware, California or New York. A French court reads that choice through Regulation (EC) No 593/2008, known as Rome I, which applies even when the chosen law is not that of an EU country (Article 2). Article 8 lets the parties choose the law of an employment contract, but the choice may not deprive the employee of the protection of the rules that cannot be set aside by agreement under the law that would apply without a choice: the law of the country where she habitually works. Recital 36 treats work abroad as temporary, and the habitual country as unchanged, when the employee is expected to resume working in her country of origin.

For the engineer in Lyon with no return date, France is where she habitually works. Your US contract stays valid, and French protective rules apply alongside it. Among them, verified today on service-public.gouv.fr: a legal working week of 35 hours, or 1,607 hours a year, and paid leave of 2.5 working days per month worked, or 30 working days a year. The 35-hour week and paid leave for US startups and how to terminate an employee in France cover working time and dismissal in detail.

She can also sue you in France. Under Regulation (EU) No 1215/2012, known as Brussels I bis, an employer domiciled outside the EU may be sued in the courts of the place where the employee habitually works (Article 21). A forum clause binds her only if agreed after the dispute arose or if it adds courts she may use (Article 23), so a clause sending every dispute to Delaware does not stop a claim in France.

Permanent Establishment: The Corporate Tax Question

This question concerns your company, not her. Under article 5 of the France-US tax treaty, a US company has a permanent establishment in France if it has a fixed place of business there through which it carries on its business, or if a person acting for it habitually exercises in France an authority to conclude contracts in its name. If France finds one, article 7 lets it tax the profits attributable to it. An engineer writing code from her apartment and a sales director closing French customers from Lyon sit at opposite ends of that test, analyzed role by role in does a remote employee in France create a permanent establishment?. The question exists whichever payroll option you choose, and an Employer of Record does not settle it.

Her Right to Live and Work in France

Service-public.gouv.fr states that the visitor visa or card does not allow work and that no work authorization can be requested for its holder. Some statuses already carry the right to work, among them the vie privée et familiale card, the talent card and the resident card, and the employer then requests nothing. Otherwise the employer obtains a work authorization before she starts, online. Which French visa lets your employee work for a US company compares the statuses that fit, and how to get a work visa in France as an American covers the employer-sponsored route.

Your Four Options Compared

OptionWhat it settlesWhat stays exposedWhen it fits
Change nothing: US payroll onlyNothing on the French sideFrench contributions unpaid from day one, undeclared employment, no French withholding, French labor law and courts, permanent establishment, possibly no right to workNever for an employee who lives and works in France
US payroll with a US certificate of coverageUS Social Security continues, exemption from French contributions under the agreementOnly for a temporary transfer you decide, 5 years at most; private health insurance; French withholding and tax representative; permanent establishmentA defined assignment with a return date
Employer of RecordThe provider is the French employer: contract, payroll, contributions, withholdingPortage limits: an occasional task or expertise you lack, 36 months per assignment; permanent establishment; her right to workA bridge while you decide on France, or a role that fits portage
Say no or agree a return dateNo French employment to runThe employee may leave; a short working stay still needs a certificate of coverage and a status that allows the workThe role cannot be done from France, or the company will not carry the risk

Source: ssa.gov and cleiss.fr (detached-worker rule, SE 404-02, durations), urssaf.fr (foreign firms, DPAE sanctions), bofip.impots.gouv.fr (BOI-IR-PAS-10-10-10 and BOI-IR-PAS-30-10-10), eur-lex.europa.eu (Rome I, Brussels I bis), code.travail.gouv.fr (L1254-3 and L1254-4), legifrance.gouv.fr (France-US tax treaty, articles 5, 7 and 15).

Two routes sit outside the table: registering your US company as a foreign employer with Urssaf, explained in hiring in France without a French entity with the payroll side in paying an employee in France from a US payroll, and opening a French company, described in setting up a SARL or SAS.

Take the hypothetical engineer again, at a 40-person SaaS company in Austin. She was not sent and has no return date, so the certificate route is closed. An Employer of Record makes the provider her French employer, but portage salarial, the framework Deel’s France page names, has limits: under article L1254-3 of the Code du travail, a client uses a portage employee only for an occasional task outside its normal and permanent activity or for expertise it lacks, and article L1254-4 caps an assignment at 36 months. Building the product is the company’s normal activity, so for her the EOR is a bridge toward registering in France or opening an entity, as Employer of Record in France: how it works and when you need one explains.

When an Employer of Record Fits

An Employer of Record stops the exposure of the first row quickly while you decide what comes next. Deel’s France page describes its EOR as a way to hire in France without your own French entity, with Deel handling local law, tax, benefits and payroll, and says a hire “could start in as little as 2 days”. Deel’s pricing page lists EOR from $599 per employee per month, on top of the salary and French employer contributions, detailed in how much it costs to employ someone in France.

Book a free consultation with Deel to see how an Employer of Record would work for an employee moving to France (affiliate link). The consultation is for companies: book it with your work email address, and bring her role, her gross salary, her planned start date in France and her immigration status.

An EOR is not always the answer. If you will open a French entity within months, Deel’s France page says a company with its own French entity can use its PEO or Global Payroll services for direct employees. If the move is a genuine temporary assignment that fits the certificate of coverage, she can stay on your payroll, with French withholding and a tax representative once she is a French tax resident. And if she will negotiate or sign customer contracts from France, an EOR solves payroll but not the permanent establishment question.

Employer Checklist

  1. Get the facts in writing: move date, whether she plans to return, where she will live, what she will do from France.
  2. Check her right to work before agreeing a start date in France.
  3. Decide the social security route: a certificate only for a transfer you decide with an end within 5 years, otherwise French coverage.
  4. Pick the employer: your US company registered with Urssaf, an Employer of Record, or a French entity.
  5. Set up French withholding and an accredited tax representative before her first French payday if your US company stays the employer.
  6. Review the contract against French law: working time, paid leave, termination, the forum clause.
  7. Review her role for permanent establishment risk: contract authority, title, where deals are decided, any office you pay for.
  8. Diary the dates: the end of a certificate, the 36-month limit of a portage assignment, her residence permit renewal.

FAQ

Can a US company employ someone in France without a French entity?

Yes. It registers with the Urssaf service for foreign firms, files the pre-hiring declaration, pays French contributions monthly and withholds French income tax through an accredited tax representative. The alternative is an Employer of Record, which becomes the French employer.

Can my employee stay on US payroll and keep paying US Social Security?

Only during a temporary transfer your company decides, expected to last 5 years or less, covered by a certificate from SSA and with private health insurance in France. An employee who moves for good is covered by French social security.

Does a US employment contract under Delaware law protect us?

Not from French protective rules. Under Article 8 of Rome I, the choice of law cannot deprive an employee of the protection of the rules of the country where she habitually works, and under Brussels I bis she can sue an employer based outside the EU in the courts of that place.

Do we have to withhold French income tax?

Yes, once she is a French tax resident working in France. BOFiP treats a foreign employer with no French establishment like a French one in principle, and a US employer must have an accredited tax representative.

Conclusion

When an employee moves to France, French social security, French withholding and French employment protections follow her from the first day, whatever your payroll system and whatever law her contract names. The certificate of coverage helps only for a temporary assignment you decide. The real choice is between registering your company in France, using an Employer of Record as employer or bridge, and opening a French entity, with the permanent establishment question and her right to work checked in every case. If an Employer of Record fits, book a free consultation with Deel (affiliate link) with your work email address.

What is your main reason for moving to France?

Your visa decides whether you are allowed to work at all.

What Americans get wrong about moving to France, and the number, form or deadline that fixes it. Straight to your inbox.

One email a week. Real numbers, nothing else.

Written by

Aurelio Maurici

Co-Founder, EasyFranceNow

Aurelio Maurici is a French entrepreneur and co-founder of EasyFranceNow. His work focuses on the intersection of French administration, banking constraints affecting U.S. nationals, tax residency and cross-border reporting, healthcare enrollment, and the procedural realities Americans encounter while settling in France.

Related articles

More in Work & Business

More articles by Aurelio Maurici

View all