Does a Remote Employee in France Create a Permanent Establishment for Your Company?
By Aurelio Maurici Co-Founder, Master of Business Law, Aix-Marseille Université III
Published
This post contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

In this article
- What the France-US Treaty Calls a Permanent Establishment
- When a Home Office Becomes a Fixed Place of Business
- When an Employee Becomes a Dependent Agent
- What Happens If France Finds a Permanent Establishment
- Permanent Establishment Risk by Role
- What Lowers the Risk
- What an Employer of Record Changes and What It Does Not
- FAQ
- Conclusion
This guide is for founders, CFOs, HR and legal leads at US companies that have, or are about to have, one person working in France, and who need to know whether that makes the company taxable there. If you are a freelancer running your own US LLC from France, it is not written for you: read when a US LLC is taxed in France instead. It covers what the France-US tax treaty calls a permanent establishment, when a home office counts, when an employee becomes a dependent agent, what France taxes if it finds one, the risk role by role, what lowers it, and what an Employer of Record changes. This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Rules change, and your situation may differ: always verify current requirements with the relevant French authorities or a licensed professional.
What the France-US Treaty Calls a Permanent Establishment
The starting point is article 7 of the France-US tax treaty signed on August 31, 1994: the business profits of a US company are taxable only in the US, unless the company carries on business in France through a permanent establishment situated there. If it does, France may tax the profits, but only those attributable to that establishment. Article 5 then defines the term (établissement stable in the French text) with two tests:
- A fixed place of business through which the company carries on all or part of its business (article 5(1)). The treaty lists examples, starting with a place of management, a branch and an office (article 5(2)).
- A dependent agent: a person, other than an independent agent, who acts for the company and has, and habitually exercises, in France an authority to conclude contracts in the company’s name (article 5(5)). The company then has a permanent establishment for all the activities that person carries on for it.
Three carve-outs limit both tests. A fixed place used solely for storage, display or delivery of goods, for purchasing goods or collecting information, or for any other activity of a preparatory or auxiliary character is not a permanent establishment (article 5(4)), and an agent whose activity stays within that list does not create one either. A broker, general commission agent or other agent of independent status acting in the ordinary course of its business does not create one (article 5(6)). And a subsidiary is not a permanent establishment of its parent by the mere fact of control (article 5(7)). The 2009 amendment to the treaty, published on Légifrance, rewrote other articles but not articles 5 and 7.
Two background points. French domestic law reaches further than the treaty: BOFiP, the tax administration’s official doctrine, taxes a foreign company that operates an establishment in France, acts through representatives without an independent professional status, or completes a full commercial cycle there. The treaty narrows that for a company that is a US resident under its article 4, which is why an LLC owned by someone living in France needs a separate analysis. And the multilateral instrument France signed in 2017, which widened the agent test in many French treaties to a person who habitually plays the principal role leading to contracts (BOI-INT-DG-20-25-20-20), does not reach this one: the United States is not on the BOFiP list of treaties it modifies, in its version of April 29, 2026. The 1994 wording governs.
When a Home Office Becomes a Fixed Place of Business
BOFiP reads the fixed place test as three conditions (BOI-INT-DG-20-20-10, § 40): premises, equipment or a location that the company has at its disposal; a place fixed in one spot with a degree of permanence; and an activity of its own, which normally means the company’s personnel are there. An office or desk your company rents in France meets the first condition at once. A preparatory or auxiliary activity would escape under article 5(4), but writing your product or serving your customers is the business itself.
The employee’s own home is the harder case. The OECD, in its 2021 guidance on tax treaties, summarizes paragraphs 18 and 19 of the Commentary on article 5 of its Model:
- Intermittent work at an employee’s home does not put the home at the company’s disposal.
- A home office may be a permanent establishment if it is used on a continuous basis for the company’s business and the company has required the employee to use it, for example by not providing an office where the nature of the job clearly requires one.
- A cross-border worker who chooses to work from home rather than from the office made available to her does not put her home at the company’s disposal.
That guidance was written for pandemic teleworking and said so: once the public health measures ended, the facts would need a fresh look. Two cautions apply in France. BOFiP recalls that the Conseil d’État declines to interpret a treaty through commentaries published after it was signed (§ 110), and the France-US treaty dates from 1994. Yet in the 2020 decision discussed below, the same court cited commentaries of 2003 and 2005 as confirming its reading of a 1968 treaty. Treat the Commentary as a strong guide to how tax administrations reason, not as a safe harbor. A fully remote company that offers no office anywhere should not assume the “not required” argument is available.
Your visa decides whether you are allowed to work at all.
What Americans get wrong about moving to France, and the number, form or deadline that fixes it. Straight to your inbox.
One email a week. Real numbers, nothing else.
When an Employee Becomes a Dependent Agent
For most remote employees the agent test is the real risk. BOFiP (§ 50) defines the dependent agent as a person, employed or not, who is legally and economically dependent on the company. Three of its points matter to a US company:
- Negotiating is enough: the agent must be empowered to deal with the company’s contracts, meaning to negotiate all their elements, and once that is so the activity keeps its permanent establishment character even if the contracts are actually signed at the company’s headquarters.
- Stability: the agent’s presence must be stable; a temporary assignment does not create a permanent establishment.
- Core activity: an agent who only buys goods for the company does not create one.
The Conseil d’État took the same line in its decision of December 11, 2020, no. 420174, on an Irish company of a US online marketing group selling through a French sister company. The French staff chose which advertisers to contract with and handled every task leading to the contract, while the Irish company set the model contract and general pricing and signed in a way the court called automatic. The court held that a person who habitually decides on transactions that the foreign company merely ratifies, and which then bind it, exercises the authority the treaty describes, even without formally concluding contracts in its name, and sent the case back to the court of appeal. The France-Ireland wording it applied is close to article 5(5) of the US treaty.
How often is habitually? The OECD guidance cites paragraph 98 of the 2017 Commentary: the frequency needed depends on the nature of the contracts and of the business. There is no fixed number of contracts below which the test is safe.
What Happens If France Finds a Permanent Establishment
Article 7 of the treaty attributes to the establishment the profits it would have made as a distinct and separate enterprise, and allows the deduction of expenses reasonably connected with those profits, including executive and general administrative expenses wherever incurred. On that base:
- Corporate tax: the normal rate is 25%, according to Entreprendre Service Public, verified on February 17, 2026.
- Filing: an annual return (form 2065) within three months of the year-end, or by the second working day after May 1 for a December 31 year-end, and four quarterly installments plus a balance. Impots.gouv.fr sends a foreign company with a permanent establishment to the business tax office covering the place where the establishment is located.
- Penalties for returns not filed: 10% without formal notice or when the return arrives within 30 days of one, 40% when it does not, and 80% when the tax administration discovers an occult activity, without any notice (BOI-CF-INF-10-20-10), on top of late-payment interest.
- The reach-back: for an occult activity, defined as one never declared to a business formalities center or registry and for which no return was filed on time, the tax administration can reassess until the end of the tenth year after the year concerned. BOI-CF-PGR-10-70 gives as an example an activity carried on in France by a foreign company behind a representative office, a liaison office or a structure that masks it.
For a company that never registered in France because it believed it had none, that exposure is the reason to settle the question before an audit does.
Permanent Establishment Risk by Role
The table applies the treaty tests and the BOFiP doctrine above to common remote roles. It is a reading of the criteria: the facts of each role decide.
| Role in France | Fixed place test (art. 5(1) and 5(2)) | Dependent agent test (art. 5(5)) | Risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Software engineer working from home, no customer contracts | Home not at the company’s disposal unless the company requires it; an office the company rents counts | No authority to conclude or negotiate contracts | Low, if no place is at the company’s disposal |
| Marketing or support, no negotiation of terms | Same as the engineer; collecting information can be preparatory under art. 5(4) | No contracts concluded or negotiated | Low |
| Sales lead who negotiates all terms, contracts signed in the US | Same as the engineer | Negotiating all elements is enough under BOFiP; deals the company only ratifies count under the 2020 Conseil d’État decision | High |
| Sales lead who signs customer contracts | Same as the engineer | Authority to conclude contracts, habitually exercised | High |
| Country manager running the French business | A place of management is listed in art. 5(2); BOFiP counts a regional, technical or commercial management seat | Usually holds contract authority | High |
| Independent reseller acting for several companies in its ordinary business | Not your place of business | Independent agent exception of art. 5(6) | Low for your company |
Source: France-US tax treaty, articles 5 and 7 (legifrance.gouv.fr); BOI-INT-DG-20-20-10, § 40 to 70 (bofip.impots.gouv.fr); Conseil d’État, December 11, 2020, no. 420174 (legifrance.gouv.fr); OECD guidance of January 21, 2021 (oecd.org).
What Lowers the Risk
None of this removes the risk, but each point changes a fact the tests look at:
- Keep deal decisions in the US in substance: pricing, acceptance and approval made by people outside France, with records that show it. A signature in the US that rubber-stamps a French decision did not help in the 2020 decision.
- Grant no signing authority and no power of attorney to the person in France, and keep job titles and contracts consistent with that scope.
- Put no place at the company’s disposal: no office, desk or storage rented in France in the company’s name, and a written record of where the company offers an office.
- Keep management decisions outside France: a place of management is the first example in article 5(2).
- Prefer preparatory and auxiliary roles for France, such as market research or information gathering, which article 5(4) treats as outside the definition.
- Review the role every year: an engineer who starts closing French customers changes the analysis.
If the role must sell in France, a French subsidiary that sells in its own name changes the structure: it is a French taxpayer and is not a permanent establishment of its parent by control alone. BOFiP adds (§ 80) that a subsidiary can still be one if it meets the fixed place or agent test, which is what the 2020 case was about. Setting up a SARL or SAS covers the formation.
What an Employer of Record Changes and What It Does Not
An Employer of Record changes who employs the person. Deel’s France page describes its EOR as a way to hire in France without your own French entity, with Deel handling local law, tax, benefits and payroll, and Deel’s pricing page lists EOR from $599 per employee per month. That settles the French employment contract, contributions and withholding, the subject of Employer of Record in France: how it works and when you need one. Registering your own company as a foreign employer, the other route, is in hiring in France without a French entity, and it leaves the tax question exactly where it was.
It does not change what the person does for your company, and the treaty looks at that. BOFiP defines the dependent agent as a person employed by the company or not, so a sales lead employed by an EOR who habitually concludes or negotiates contracts for your US company can still be your dependent agent. For an engineer, an EOR handles the employment and the permanent establishment analysis usually stays favorable. For a country manager, it solves payroll and leaves the tax question open.
Book a free consultation with Deel to see how an Employer of Record works in France (affiliate link). The consultation is for companies: book it with your work email address and bring the role description, since the permanent establishment question starts with what the person will do.
An EOR is not the right answer in three cases. If you are about to open a French entity, Deel’s France page says a company with its own entity can use its PEO or Global Payroll services instead. If the person is a genuine independent contractor, Deel lists contractor management from $49 per contractor per month, and the misclassification trap is the risk to check. And if the role is to sign French customers, plan the subsidiary or the tax filings, because no employment structure moves the contracts.
FAQ
Does one remote employee create a permanent establishment in France?
Not by being there. Under article 5 of the France-US treaty, she creates one if she works from a fixed place of business at the company’s disposal, or if she habitually exercises in France an authority to conclude contracts in the company’s name. An engineer with no customer role usually meets neither test.
Does working from home create a permanent establishment?
According to the OECD Commentary summarized in the OECD’s 2021 guidance, a home office can be one if it is used continuously for the business and the company required it, for example by providing no office where the job needs one. Occasional home working does not put the home at the company’s disposal.
Does an Employer of Record eliminate permanent establishment risk?
No. The EOR becomes the employer, but BOFiP defines the dependent agent as a person employed by the company or not. Someone employed by an EOR who habitually concludes or negotiates contracts for your company can still create a permanent establishment.
What if contracts are always signed in the US?
French doctrine counts an agent who negotiates all the elements of contracts even if they are signed at headquarters. In 2020 the Conseil d’État held that a court erred in ruling out a permanent establishment where the foreign company’s signature was automatic and the French team decided the deals.
What tax applies if France finds a permanent establishment?
French corporate tax on the profits attributable to it, at a 25% normal rate, with an annual return, quarterly installments and, for years never filed, penalties of 10% to 80%.
Can a contractor create a permanent establishment?
Yes, if the contractor is in fact dependent. The treaty excludes agents of independent status acting in the ordinary course of their business, and BOFiP defines dependence as legal and economic, so a contractor who works only for you and closes your deals can fall on the wrong side.
Conclusion
One person in France creates a permanent establishment for a US company in two situations: a place of business the company has at its disposal, or an authority to conclude contracts exercised habitually, which French doctrine and the Conseil d’État read to include negotiating deals that the US only signs. An engineer working from home is usually outside both tests; a sales lead closing French deals or a country manager usually is not, whoever employs them. Decide the role first, keep decisions and places outside France where the role allows it, and when an Employer of Record fits, book a free consultation with Deel (affiliate link) with your work email address. The employee side of the same move is in what a US employer owes an employee moving to France.
What is your main reason for moving to France?
Your visa decides whether you are allowed to work at all.
What Americans get wrong about moving to France, and the number, form or deadline that fixes it. Straight to your inbox.
One email a week. Real numbers, nothing else.
Written by
Aurelio Maurici
Co-Founder, EasyFranceNow
Aurelio Maurici is a French entrepreneur and co-founder of EasyFranceNow. His work focuses on the intersection of French administration, banking constraints affecting U.S. nationals, tax residency and cross-border reporting, healthcare enrollment, and the procedural realities Americans encounter while settling in France.






